Baby Daddy

Ben continues his determined search for the enigmatic Elle. Meanwhile, Danny and Riley seek medical care for Riley's pregnancy, with Bonnie eager to take part in the process. Tucker returns from Los Angeles but keeps the details of his trip a secret.

Ben seeks Danny's assistance to uncover the truth about Tucker's recent date after discovering intriguing information. Meanwhile, Brad is arrested by the FBI just as Bonnie and Brad are about to begin their worldwide trip.

Ben thinks he's found a casual connection in Riley, but she challenges his assumptions about their relationship. At the same time, Danny finds himself competing in an unexpected professional wrestling match.

Tucker is surprised to learn his Mother's Day special has been nominated for a New York Entertainment Award, and his plans for Bonnie to impersonate his mother at the ceremony are disrupted when his real mother unexpectedly decides to attend. Meanwhile, Riley begins to show her pregnancy and fears it may hinder her chances of being promoted to junior partner.

Sam returns, hoping to rekindle her relationship with Ben, though he is uncertain, still focused on finding Elle. Meanwhile, Bonnie begins working as Elle's realtor, unaware of her connection to Ben. Danny and Tucker participate in a charity ice skating event featuring Emma's favorite princess, while Riley works on developing parenting skills.

Danny's overprotectiveness of Riley, who is pregnant, leads Ben to plan a surprise day off for her, including a hike in the woods. Concerned about Ben's irresponsibility, Danny secretly follows them, only to discover that Riley shares his fears about becoming a parent. Meanwhile, Bonnie suspects her boss may be responsible for Brad's imprisonment and teams up with Tucker to gather evidence in an attempt to clear Brad's name.

Ben, feeling left out when Bonnie plans a cruise for Danny to celebrate his new fatherhood, challenges him to a "Wheeler War" to determine who is more deserving of the trip. At the same time, Tucker encounters his ex-girlfriend at a Lamaze class, leading him to exaggerate his life achievements in an attempt to impress her, with the lies spiraling into increasingly awkward situations.

Ben encounters a runaway bride who shares his belief in destiny, complicating his interactions with Elle. Tucker helps him navigate the situation and regain the bridesmaids' favor without incident. Meanwhile, Danny and Riley begin a babymoon cruise, joined unexpectedly by Bonnie after she learns of Danny's elopement plans.

Tucker, learning that his ex-girlfriend Sondra is single, confides in Ben about his lingering feelings, prompting Ben to offer to act as Sondra's rebound to help Tucker. Meanwhile, Bonnie and Riley bond while camping out for a crib sale, and Danny attempts to babyproof their apartment but ends up causing more damage than improvement.

Danny and Ben attempt to discover the sex of Riley and Danny's baby despite her wishes, leading to a series of misunderstandings. At the same time, Riley works to prove Brad's innocence during his final trial, and Tucker tries out for a spot on a courtroom reality show.

Riley waits anxiously at home for the baby's arrival, while Tucker assists Danny in choosing a gift for Riley's labor. Meanwhile, Ben begins to doubt his parenting abilities when Emma's questions about her missing mother arise in the context of an upcoming school talent show.