Every Year After

Percy Fraser returns to Barry's Bay after ten years following the death of Sue Florek, a cherished local figure and mother figure to Percy. Confronted by old acquaintances and buried secrets, Percy grapples with the bittersweet memories of her first summer at the lake—marked by her relationship with Sue's son, Sam—and the regrets that led her to leave.

Tensions rise between the brothers at The Tavern as Jordie spends time with Chantal and uncovers a lie from Delilah. Meanwhile, Percy begins to suspect her reasons for coming were deeper than just visiting Sue, and reconnecting with Sam brings back memories of a pivotal Truth or Dare game from her second summer in Barry's Bay.

Delilah confides in Jordie, Chantal turns to Charlie for assistance during a personal crisis, and Percy and Sam's growing closeness reignites old tensions reminiscent of their high school days, including memories of a power outage and a passionate bonfire party.

The reading of Sue's will shocks everyone, particularly Sam and Charlie, who are angry, while Percy is confused and emotionally overwhelmed. Sue, Delilah, and Chantal confront difficult truths about themselves and their relationships, and Percy reflects on the fearless version of herself from the past.

Drew arrives with an unexpected guest, causing tension. Delilah and Charlie face a significant decision, while Sam makes a choice that alters the course of their life, prompting Percy to distract herself from her emotions. Feelings of longing and jealousy resurface, echoing a past New Year's Eve party where a surprise guest and a midnight kiss stirred emotions.

Percy's secret is revealed, causing tension among the group. A search party is formed by an unexpected group, while Percy focuses on helping Delilah and reconciling past mistakes. Meanwhile, as Percy and Sam's relationship deteriorates, flashbacks show the beginnings of their teenage romance.

Tensions rise as old resentments resurface and a romantic conflict intensifies, while Charlie and Percy confront the consequences of their past actions. Percy grapples with a new secret that adds to her turmoil, reflecting on a pivotal moment from the previous summer that changed everything.

On the day of the memorial, the Barry's Bay crew grapples with unresolved feelings and difficult choices. Charlie attempts to mend relationships, Delilah experiences a moment of clarity, and Chantal wrestles with a tough decision between logic and emotion, while Percy and Sam remain uncertain about their own feelings. The group reflects on what to keep and what to release as they navigate the intersection of past and present.