Episode 4— Honey

Eric Matheson (played by Garret Dillahunt) is trying to prove that he did not murder his wife. Detective Torres is assigned to the case and visits the victim's sister at her home. Matheson later finds Torres's car and enters it after she leaves the door unlocked. When Torres returns, Matheson takes her hostage at gunpoint and forces her to drive to the Lightman Group offices. Cal Lightman negotiates with Matheson, offering to let all the employees go in exchange for his help in proving Matheson's innocence. Matheson agrees, and Foster, Loker, Reynolds, and Torres work to solve the case, while Loker begins to question whether they should have contacted the police. The team discovers that Matheson is actually innocent and that his wife was killed by a creditor. Matheson demands to meet the creditor, stating he will kill either the creditor or Cal. Cal offers himself up for death, but Foster, Loker, and Reynolds manage to lower Matheson's guard by having a disguised Loker falsely recount the final moments of Matheson's wife. As Matheson is about to kill Loker in a fit of rage, Reynolds draws his gun and shoots Matheson, disarming him. The episode concludes with Lightman at Foster's house, asking if he can stay in her spare room for the night.